What is PCB Warpage?
PCB warpage refers to the distortion or deformation of a printed circuit board (PCB) from its intended flat shape. This can occur during the manufacturing process or later due to environmental factors. The two main types of PCB warpage are bow and twist.
Bow
Bow is when the PCB curves up or down along its length or width. It’s like if you held the two ends of the board and the middle sagged down (positive bow) or curved up (negative bow).
Bow is quantified by measuring the maximum vertical displacement of the board from a flat reference plane:
| Bow Direction | Description |
|---|---|
| Positive bow | Center of PCB is higher than edges |
| Negative bow | Center of PCB is lower than edges |
| No bow | PCB is flat with no vertical displacement |
Acceptable bow depends on the board dimensions, thickness, and application. Industry standards like IPC-TM-650 define bow limits. For example:
| Board Thickness | Maximum Bow |
|---|---|
| < 1.6 mm | 0.75% |
| 1.6 – 2.0 mm | 0.50% |
| 2.0 – 3.2 mm | 0.30% |
So for a 100 mm long, 1.6 mm thick board, the maximum allowed positive or negative bow would be 0.75 mm.
Twist
Twist, on the other hand, is when the PCB deforms in a rotational manner, with the four corners no longer in the same plane. Picture grabbing the board by opposite corners and giving it a slight twist.
Twist is harder to measure than bow, since the displacement is angular rather than just vertical. It’s quantified by the maximum vertical distance between any two corners.
Like bow, acceptable twist depends on PCB size and application. Typical maximum twist specs are:
| Board Diagonal | Maximum Twist |
|---|---|
| < 150 mm | 2.0% |
| 150 – 300 mm | 1.0% |
| > 300 mm | 0.7% |
So a 200 mm diagonal board would be allowed up to 2 mm of twist.
Causes of PCB Warpage
There are several reasons why a PCB might develop bow or twist:
CTE Mismatch
The coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) measures how much a material expands when heated. If the CTE of the different layers in a PCB are not well matched, uneven expansion can lead to warping.
For example, the CTE of copper is about 17 ppm/°C, while FR-4 laminate is around 14 ppm/°C in the X-Y direction but 50-70 ppm/°C in the Z direction. During thermal cycling, the copper wants to expand more than the FR-4 in the X-Y plane, putting stress on the board.
CTE mismatches are a bigger concern in boards with:
– Thicker or more numerous copper layers
– Higher layer count
– Thicker boards
– Leadless components (BGA, QFN)
– Stiff components (ceramic capacitors)
– Heavier copper weights
– Unbalanced copper distribution
Uneven Heating
If one side or area of the board gets hotter than another during manufacturing (soldering, curing, etc.), the hotter part will expand more and can cause warpage.
Common heating imbalances include:
– Top vs. bottom of board in reflow oven
– Center vs. edges of board
– Areas with heavier copper or more components
– Boards near edge of panel in multi-PCB panels
Moisture Absorption
FR-4 and other PCB Laminates readily absorb atmospheric moisture. If one side absorbs more than the other, that side will expand and cause bowing. This is more pronounced in thicker, multi-layer boards.
Mechanical Stresses
Residual stresses from the PCB manufacturing process, especially lamination and drilling, can contribute to warpage. Aggressive routing paths, improper material handling, and uneven forces during depaneling can also physically bend the board.
Design Factors
Certain PCB design choices make warpage more likely:
– Asymmetric layer stack-up
– Uneven copper distribution
– Inadequate support for large components
– Abrupt transitions in board thickness
– Insufficient anchor points for connectors
– Acute angles in board outline
Effects of PCB Warpage
Warped PCBs cause problems in both manufacturing and end use:
Component Placement Issues
Pick-and-place machines and solder paste printers rely on the PCB being flat. If it’s warped, components may be placed inaccurately or not at all. Fine-pitch devices like BGAs are especially sensitive.
Soldering Defects
Gaps between component leads and pads due to warpage can result in open circuits or weak solder joints. Bridging is also more likely if warpage causes leads to touch adjacent pads. If the board warps during reflow, components could be knocked out of place.
Poor Board Fit
A warped board may not fit properly in its intended enclosure or mate correctly with connectors and other boards. Trying to force a fit can crack solder joints and damage components.
Uneven Mechanical Stresses
Attaching a warped board can put uneven stresses on it, potentially leading to trace/via cracking and premature failure, especially with vibration or mechanical shock.
Compromised Cooling
Thermally conductive paths between hot components and heatsinks or PCB planes can be disrupted by gaps caused by warpage. This impairs cooling.
Controlling PCB Warpage
While some warpage is often inevitable, there are several ways to minimize it in design and manufacturing:
Material Selection
- Use FR-4 or other laminates with low Z-axis CTE
- Select leadframe and component materials that match board CTE
- Consider high-Tg laminates for better thermal stability
- Use consistent materials in multi-layer boards
Stack-up Design
- Use symmetrical layer stack-up
- Balance copper on innerlayers
- Minimize use of heavy copper weights
- Use at least three laminated layers
Component Placement
- Avoid clustering heavy components in one area
- Provide adequate anchor points for connectors
- Use corners or edges of board for large components
- Distribute copper pour evenly
Manufacturing Controls
- Bake PCBs prior to assembly to remove moisture
- Ensure even heating in reflow ovens and curing
- Use vacuum or weights to hold boards flat
- Allow boards to cool evenly to room temperature
- Handle panels carefully to avoid flexing
- Use routed tabs or pizza-cutter depaneling
Design Rules
- Round sharp corners in board outline
- Avoid abrupt changes in board thickness
- Minimize large cutouts in board
- Provide stress relief near connectors
- Define maximum allowable warpage
Testing for PCB Warpage
There are a few common methods to measure PCB bow and twist:
Visual Inspection
For grossly warped boards, a simple visual check may suffice. The board is placed on a flat surface and any gaps or rocking noted. This is fast but subjective and not suitable for finer warpage.
Feeler Gauges
Thin metal strips of precise thicknesses, feeler gauges can be used to measure the gap under a warped board. The maximum gauge thickness that fits under the board is its warpage value.
Dial Indicator
A dial indicator is used to measure the vertical displacement of the board surface relative to a flat reference. The board is supported at 3-4 points and the indicator moved across the surface in a grid pattern, recording the highest and lowest points.
Shadow Moiré
This optical method involves projecting a grating pattern onto the PCB surface and observing the resulting interference pattern (Moiré fringes). The spacing and direction of the fringes correspond to the surface contours, allowing warpage to be mapped.
3D Scanning
Laser or structured light scanners can map the entire PCB surface to generate a 3D model. Comparing this to a nominal flat model allows warpage to be calculated. This is the most thorough method but requires specialized equipment.
FAQ
What is the difference between bow and twist in a PCB?
Bow is when the PCB curves up or down along its length or width, while twist is when it deforms in a rotational manner, with the corners no longer coplanar. Bow is a vertical displacement, twist is an angular one.
What causes PCB warpage?
The main causes are CTE mismatches between board layers, uneven heating during manufacturing, moisture absorption, mechanical stresses, and certain design factors like asymmetric stack-ups and uneven copper distribution.
What problems can PCB warpage cause?
Warped boards can lead to component placement issues, soldering defects, poor board fit, uneven mechanical stresses, and compromised cooling. This affects both manufacturing and reliability.
How can you prevent PCB warpage?
Warpage can be minimized by selecting materials with matched CTEs, using a symmetrical stack-up, balancing copper distribution, providing adequate component support, ensuring even heating during manufacturing, and following design rules to avoid stress concentrations.
How is PCB warpage measured?
Methods include visual inspection, feeler gauges, dial indicators, shadow Moiré, and 3D scanning. The choice depends on the degree of warpage and the desired accuracy and thoroughness of measurement.
No responses yet